Eros vs Safety: Rethinking Infidelity

Infidelity is one of the most painful and destabilizing experiences in intimate relationships. It can feel like a betrayal so profound that it calls into question everything we thought we knew—about our partner, about our bond, and even about ourselves. Yet, as psychotherapist Esther Perel suggests, perhaps there’s more to infidelity than meets the eye. Instead of viewing it solely through the lens of moral failure or personal inadequacy, she invites us to explore it as a complex and layered phenomenon—one that can reveal deeper truths about longing, identity, and modern love.

GET HELP NOW

The Paradox of Modern Love

We live in an era in which we expect one person to be our best friend, our passionate lover, co-parent, emotional confidante, and life partner. With these heightened expectations comes an equally intense fear of betrayal. Perel calls this the "romantic ideal" - emotional monogamy and erotic exclusivity become the pillars of trust. But what happens when that ideal collapses?

Affairs are no longer just about sex. More often, they’re about desire—desire for attention, novelty, aliveness, or a lost version of the self. Those of us who commit infidelity don’t always do so to leave our partners; rather, those who stray may be trying to reconnect with a part of themselves they feel has been buried by the routines and roles of everyday life.

The Drivers Behind Affairs

Contrary to popular belief, infidelity isn’t always a symptom of a bad relationship. Many people report feeling satisfied in their marriage and still end up having an affair. Often, infidelity is less about the other person and more about inner conflict. The betraying partner often is seeking a part of themselves long dead; the flame stoked by extramarital intimacy is often an internal one, a feeling long lost. Further, those who stray may struggle with feelings of grief and loss related to this part, as well as myriad feelings of despair, emptiness and internal isolation. The affair therefore becomes an avenue for reconnection with lost internal parts of self. It may stem from a longing for freedom, youth, adventure, or simply to feel desired again.

Esther Perel famously notes, “When we seek the gaze of another, it isn’t always our partner we are turning away from, but the person we have become.” This reframe doesn’t excuse the betrayal, but it deepens the conversation.

The Trauma of Betrayal—and the Potential for Growth

Infidelity is traumatic. The shock, anger, grief, and confusion it triggers can shatter the foundation of trust and security. But not all affairs spell the end of the relationship. For some couples, it becomes an unexpected opportunity to redefine their connection, confront long-avoided truths, and create a more honest and resilient bond.

Perel encourages couples not just to ask “Will we stay together?” but also “What kind of relationship do we want to build moving forward?” Healing isn’t about returning to how things were; it’s about co-creating something new. Often in couples therapy, we frame the discovery of infidelity and the attempts of reconciliation that follow, as "the start of a new marriage." For those who emerge from an affair, the old marriage is dead. Reconciliation and recommitment offer opportunity to write a new chapter, while grieving the marriage that was lost.

Rebuilding After the Storm

For couples willing to engage in the hard work of recovery, the road ahead requires transparency, empathy, and courage. The road ahead for these couples involves acknowledgment of the pain without rushing to fix it. These couples must learn to open to one another, which involves listening deeply to both the hurt as well as the reasons behind the affair. With true listening, these people can then engage in mutual decision making with intention whether and how to rebuild trust. However, the processes and work that follow affairs also involve individual, personal-level work. Each person must engage in and explore their own personal growth, beyond the scope of marital repair. These couples then have the opportunity to experience a new relationship, with new versions of themselves; the novelty of affair can be supplanted by the excitement and newness of what is essentially a new marriage between new-yet-acquainted old lovers. Of course, in some cases, an affair ends the relationship. In others, it begins a new chapter—more vulnerable, more open, more intentional.

Moving From Judgment to Curiosity

Our cultural narrative around infidelity is often harsh and binary: victim and villain, right and wrong. But Perel urges us to look beyond moral judgments and ask deeper questions. What are we really seeking when we stray? How do our unmet needs shape our choices? And what does fidelity mean in a world in which autonomy and connection are both core human needs?

When we replace judgment with curiosity, we open the door to more honest conversations—about desire, commitment, and what it means to love in an age of infinite options.

Eroticism Versus Emotional Safety

Given the prevalence of infidelity, and the rate of divorce in modern America, it is worth exploring the dynamics within contemporary romantic relationships. Perel writes extensively about the dichotomy between erotic passion and emotional intimacy. The culture in which we live in these modern times harshly judges those who commit infidelity, while essentially pretending that affairs rarely ever happen. The reality is: infidelity is commonplace, affairs are abundant, and we are equally likely to end up divorced as stay married. Yet, we stigmatize infidelity and refuse to analyze why it occurs.

Perel poses that our expectations are entirely out-of-line. In modern America, we expect our partners to be both passionate, erotically driven lovers as well as emotionally safe best friends. Successful marriages are framed as both erotically hot and emotionally secure. However, eroticism often is rooted in the foreign, the exotic, the risky and dangerous. Passionate sex partners, driven through eros, can be strangely frightening, overpowering, and free of control. In contrast, emotionally safe friends provide a sense of security and comfort; they are familiar and close, known to us, and concretely safe. That we expect to somehow have both in our marriages, while also functioning as teammates and co-parents, is frankly absurd.

Through the discovery of infidelity and the subsequent efforts at reconciliation and reconnection, surviving couples are able to have larger, more honest conversations about these expectations and the associated relational dynamics. In this way, affairs can open doors to deeper connection.

In Closing

Infidelity is painful. It can dismantle identities and devastate families. But in the hands of couples willing to confront its lessons, it can also spark profound transformation. As Esther Perel reminds us, “An affair can be the death of a relationship—or the beginning of a new one.” Like everything else, affairs occur within the larger context of the relationship as well as our society. By working through the aftermath of discovery, surviving couples may learn to connect with one another on a deeper, more profound and honest manner.

If you're navigating the aftermath of infidelity, know that you're not alone—and that healing, though difficult, is possible.

GET HELP NOW